UPDATE: Portage man dead following fight that led to shooting - WKOW 27: Madison, WI Breaking News, Weather and Sports

UPDATE: Suspected shooter claims self defense following death of Portage man

Posted: Updated:
Calvin C. Eldridge Calvin C. Eldridge
Victor Reynolds Victor Reynolds

PORTAGE (WKOW) -- A Portage man has died after being shot following a fight Monday and the neighbor who police suspect shot him is claiming self defense.

Victor B. Reynolds, 54, died at UW Hospitals after the shooting, according to the Portage Police Department.

Calvin C. Eldridge, 49, was taken into custody and faces charges of recklessly endangering safety. He is expected to appear in Columbia County Court this week.

The Portage Police Department says its officers were called to a home in the 2800 block of Village Road about 5 p.m. Monday, May 7, 2018. Police say the two men got into a fight and one of them was shot. 

The men live in the same building and have have a history of disputes, according to Portage police.

The argument and scuffle took place in a common area, and police say they believe Reynolds engaged Eldridge and that Eldridge grabbed the gun when it went off, killing Reynolds, according to Portage police.

A teenage neighbor recorded the confrontation on her cell phone, and provided it to 27 News. 

The men are heard arguing for approximately a minute, with a woman who may be Eldridge's wife also shouting during the confrontation.  A gun shot is then heard, as is the teenager's reaction.  "He has a gun,"  she says from her position behind her family's apartment door.  "He just shot him, he just shot him."

"Victor never had a weapon,"  neighbor Heidi Cervantes says.  "I don't think he knew what was coming."

Police Lieutenant Daniel Garrigan says Eldridge had armed himself.  Garrigan says Eldridge has a state-issued, concealed carry permit.

Garrigan says Reynolds was shot in the lower leg, and was able to talk to responding officers.  Garrigan says both Reynolds and Garrigan had other injuries from the fight.  The specific cause of Reynolds' death has not been released.

A woman who may have been Eldridge's wife can be heard on the teen neighbor's recording immediately after the gun shot is fired.  "He defended himself,"  the woman says.

Prior to Reynolds' condition developing into a life-threatening situation, Garrigan says authorities planned to recommend a charge of substantial battery against him. Eldridge is claiming self defense, and police say the recklessly endangering safety charge is most appropriate, although district attorney will make the final decision on any charges.

Police officials say the men have fought in the past over issues such as the playing of loud music, and the slamming of doors.

"This was a situation that started over something foolish and just escalated out of control,"  Garrigan says.

Powered by Frankly